Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Denys's avatar

>> Ihor Kolomoisky was a 2019 supporter of Zelensky and later became a supporter of Russian propaganda.

- I have not heard anything regarding his support of propaganda.

Expand full comment
jspivack's avatar

Hello Don,

Thanks for making your assessments available to us. I posted this question below yesterday. It got some interest but not really any decisive answers. I'd be grateful to have your response. Thanks.

'Winning' is guaranteeing a secure future for an independent, democratic Ukraine. The pro-Ukraine experts I've read (O'Brien, Hodges, etc.) still don't seem to offer us a clear theory for how Ukraine 'wins' by that criterion. Someone please help us figure out what we are shooting for.

As long as Putin's regime has men, machines, and money to continue aggression, it looks like he will continue it no matter what. Maybe he'll do brief pauses to regroup and attempt to divide Ukraine's allies.

I'm in favor of better armaments to Ukraine to help save lives of Ukraine's soldiers and civilians. But battlefield victories over Russia, in Ukraine or in Russia or anywhere else, seem like they won't end the war decisively for Ukraine. Putin can just keep it going. If Ukraine liberates Crimea, Gen Hodges says the war would be over, but Putin may not get Hodges' memo or agree to follow it. Even if Ukraine somehow pushed Russia back to the 1991 borders, Putin may not concede defeat.

It looks like the war could only end in a win for Ukraine when Russia has completely exhausted itself economically, militarily, and socially/ideologically. Then it either collapses or the risk of collapse will make it have to prioritize internal threats to survival over continued aggression. At least for a generation.

But Russia's exhaustion still seems years away. It literally means burning through all the old Soviet equipment, and burning through all the money they piled up over decades, and letting the hundreds of thousands of casualties finally undermine the Putin regime's legitimacy. That is an extremely long process. Also, I don't think the main powers in the West even want it: either for a false goal of 'stability' or out a flawed strategy to keep Russia as a major power to use as a counterweight to China.

Please could you give at least a rough view of a path ahead for how Ukraine 'wins'. I'd deeply appreciate. Thanks.

Best,

John

Expand full comment
25 more comments...

No posts