Discussion about this post

User's avatar
ZenithA's avatar

It seems that everyone is literally "blinded" by current drone technology development. We tend to forget that drones are extremely soft targets. They can be easily fought by even cheaper means then they are. Amors and speed crafts appeared for a reason in the past.

With fully implementing existing anti drone technology, drone swarms, while could become a norm, would not be so dreaded.

And also with relative simplicity of organising armor protection, people would get back inside those. And then after a turn of spiral "normal" doctrine would be back, though significantly extended and updated with requirements of the time.

The most significant change though, needs to come in a multisensor recon. Where litteraly one would not be able to hide any aspect of military activity 100-150 km deep from the frontline. And then whoever wins that "middle sky" wins the whole battle, because of being able to interdict logistics 100 km deep.

So I suspect we might see a few changes of approach, and technology leaps before this war is over.

Expand full comment
Andrii's avatar

Some (likely not full) "errata" for the auto-translation of Yigal Levin's post:

"you cannot deploy and concentrate more forces than your mouth."

- more forces than a company (rota)

"pulling out "arrows" (Ukrainians call it "pysunami")."

- You can maybe translate this as "pricks" (as in "Pudding is a ***", but a more "cute/childish" version). :) And if anyone cares, the word ending in "ami" is objective case from "pisiun" (sing.) & "pisiuny" (pl.).

"and for command it is underground care and support for wired and satellite communication"

- moving underground and relying on [wired/sat comms]

"all-round military combat"

- combined arms (= общевойсковой бой)

"and controlled combat AI"

- controlled BY combat AI

"this will result in the unnecessary number of operators."

- result in not needing many operators

"“man-machine” spike"

- "man-machine" joint/seam/combination etc

Expand full comment
17 more comments...

No posts