Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Andrew Tanner's avatar

The real reason the USA blindly supports Israel in a nutshell:

Backing Israel is *essential* to the deliberately cultivated postwar myth that the USA saved the world single-handedly from evil in WW2. Problem with the narrative is that facts show most American's didn't care about Hitler's treatment of Jews or any other group the Nazis decided was subhuman that week. And though US leaders knew about the death camps, they were happy to let the Nazis waste resources on them.

Never mind reality: America is a nation built on marketing. What you believe is truth, and if someone questions you, they're on Team Bad. Even if the Nazis were only imitating what the USA did to "win the west" from those scary natives, transforming the Slavic, Jewish, Roma, and dozens of other peoples into their own indigenous victims.

Until about 1970 or so WW2 was, in the American memory, all about vengeance for Pearl Harbor with the country only reluctantly getting involved in Europe's wars again to put down Hitler, a guy plenty of Americans were fans of throughout the 1930s. Then, after Vietnam, as the nationalist myths used to justify that idiotic intervention were falling apart, the military-industrial-media complex needed a new reason for the USA to meddle all across the world, especially in the oil-rich Middle East which had become even more important as US oil reserves were depleted.

Not because direct control is required, just kinetic influence. But to sustain US involvement in the Middle East it needed a somewhat reliable ally, and thanks to the prominence many Jewish-American Zionists in US political circles (no one cared about Israel killing US sailors aboard the *Liberty*) Israel became it. But as its behavior became more brutal year after year, that posed uncomfortable questions for America's foreign policy mandarins - as it still does today.

So began the onslaught of allegations of anti-Semitism leveled against anyone who argues for treating Israel like any other country - even though plenty of non-Zionist Jews want the same. The American media began to identify the Holocaust as the reason the US had to fight in WW2, despite Americans in the 1930s absolutely disagreeing, thus connecting Israel's very existence to the war and, perversely, the brutal and often self-destructive way the Allies chose to fight it.

To see Israel claiming that Gaza is the new Dresden and the annihilation of both is justified because that's what the USA did in WW2 completes the circle. America is good and all enemies are evil and Israel is good because the Holocaust was bad and the USA saved everyone.

Hence the majority of my public school education about WW2 literally being a screening of Schindler's List. That's all Americans need to know about the nightmare. Us good, them bad, with us and them defined by powerful people who never face accountability despite this being necessary for democracy to work.

Expand full comment
Bill Flarsheim's avatar

I can best describe the moral difference between Putin and Netanyahu by saying that Netanyahu is destined for a circle of Hell one to two floors above Putin. I agree with those that say that Bibi Netanyahu is the worst Jewish leader in almost 1900 years.

Expand full comment
98 more comments...

No posts