Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Simonjakob's avatar

The problem with intercepting ballistic missiles is cost effectiveness, it always cost more to intercept a missile than to make a new one (total system costs) , the launcher always control the timing and the target location, sure Trumps golden dome and Israel's ABM umbrella can spend lavishly even extravagantly to make a statement against none state actors and failed states without a real missile force but proves totally inadequate against an enemy that can really saturate and penetrate the most solid ABM currently in the world that have ample regional buffer zone and and even more lenient target space and types to cover and comfort time window to respond as we have seen in the case of the Iranian missile strike on Tel Aviv.

In the long run strategic bombardment is won by logistics and the ability to penetrate the target defenses and manufacturing and storage infrastructure, any how missiles are poor substitute for other strategic bombardment means and simply using them to terrorize civilians and inviting a retaliation strikes against own civilians is ultimately futile and wasteful from the military sense.

Ukraine knows this and use what they got to target military infrastructure and manufacturing capacities and this should be the focus of the military aid , the Russian regime can not afford to taeget civilians if every attack was followed by a massive retaliation against Russian economic and military infrastructure in the strategic depth.

Meanwhile the ABM defence network of Ukraine can not be stretched to protect every civilian target with out exposing vital war efforts targets which is why the the Russian regime is targeting civilians to begin with

Expand full comment
Tupolev16's avatar

"Right now, the United States’ Patriot and the European SAMP-T systems are the only proven solutions deployed in Ukraine, confirmed to have successfully intercepted Russian ballistic missiles"

Actually, back in 2022 UA S-300V system downed at least one RU KH-22 (AS-4) 3M missile.

Expand full comment
15 more comments...

No posts