Most excellent! I worked 25 years in US defense logistics, for LTV and Lockheed-Martin. Most people outside the industry have no idea of "lead times", which can be frighteningly long for many critical components. I am sure the current US administration thinks they can wave a magic wand and boost production immediately, but Trump will be out of office before many of the items ordered this month will be ready for final assembly and issuing to the using troops.....
We live in hope, but I was simply commenting on the fact that lead times for precision components can run months, and sometimes years - all non-partisan..... Trump and his cronies, especially the "Secretary of War", have absolutely no idea of what they are doing , or what they should be doing.
Oh, there are so many..... The idiotic decisions by senior management - the time we designed a wing for a new aircraft, and the team designing the left wing did not talk to the team for the right wing and the result was the two teams chose different airfoils for the two wings so the plane flew one wing high. They had to add vortex generators to the low wing on the prototype to get it to fly level when trimmed out. And there are even worse - my favorite, I guess, was the time LTV engineers discovered that giant McDonnell-Douglas made a basic error in stress calculations for the vertical tail of the C-17 transport, failing to factor in drag - something so basic I can see why it might have been overlooked. MD had to re-stress the assembly and LTV then built all the tail sections for the C-17 after that. I was going to write a black comedy about my time in the defense industry, and a manager gave me the perfect title: "You Can Buy Better, but You Can't Pay More".....
Wow. I wouldn't even have considered to different teams for the wings. Was that decision made because of internal differences in the wings?
I'm glad they caught the drag issue at some point. I remember a Mars vehicle that failed because one part of the team was using feet and the other meters.
Yes, the Mars screw-up also involved Lockheed-Martin - L-M was using Imperial (feet/miles) and NASA was using metric (meters/kilometers). It did not go well..... As for the LTV non-matching wing issue, I am not sure why they had two teams designing the two wings instead of one - perhaps due to different equipment in each wing requiring different mountings and power supply details. Obviously, production Gulfstream Vs have matching wings.....
Very nice post. The bottleneck is serious, the European suppliers are not identified although you are implying PRC financial capability to "buy" said sources.
Thank you for this analysis. Value chains are really some difficult beasts. Impressive when it performs. And very brittle indeed. (They remind me of AI in that way.) I am afraid the most important lesson I take away from this is the need for most countries to look very hard at such systems when they decide on weapons. For Ukraine? Build your own.
It's easier to build simpler systems on your own. Ballistic interceptor missiles are much more difficult to design and build than ballistic missiles, and Ukraine has been working on ballistic missiles since at least 2006.
Brilliant, Don. I hope all those people (none here on Sarcastosaurus of course) who think a magic wand can be waved and PAC-3s or Aster-30s will appear instantly read this. It needs to be circulated as widely as possible.
"Wartime economy optimizes for resiliency, redundancy while peacetime economy optimized for cost, profit."
While I may have just pulled this quote out of my rear end, I think it is true.
It gets even more fun when you introduce software supply chains, where the bottleneck is security or "provenness". If you have software that works, great. Until it stops working, or gets exploited and cannot be relied on anymore, then you have a possibly huge hole in your applicaton. Maybe the developers are no longer around to outline how it's supposed to work, and what the design tradeoffs are for remaking - or maybe they work for a hostile actor (joys of open source).
I forsee fun problems in the future for f-35 and any other programs where the government does not own the source.
Most excellent! I worked 25 years in US defense logistics, for LTV and Lockheed-Martin. Most people outside the industry have no idea of "lead times", which can be frighteningly long for many critical components. I am sure the current US administration thinks they can wave a magic wand and boost production immediately, but Trump will be out of office before many of the items ordered this month will be ready for final assembly and issuing to the using troops.....
You appear to have more confidence in your democracy than the rest of the western world, perhaps.
We live in hope, but I was simply commenting on the fact that lead times for precision components can run months, and sometimes years - all non-partisan..... Trump and his cronies, especially the "Secretary of War", have absolutely no idea of what they are doing , or what they should be doing.
You either fight for a better world, which requires hope that it is possible, or you just accept the misery that comes your way.
This administration is special, but I think it's a problem central to a lot of contracts. What's your favorite story from your experiences?
Oh, there are so many..... The idiotic decisions by senior management - the time we designed a wing for a new aircraft, and the team designing the left wing did not talk to the team for the right wing and the result was the two teams chose different airfoils for the two wings so the plane flew one wing high. They had to add vortex generators to the low wing on the prototype to get it to fly level when trimmed out. And there are even worse - my favorite, I guess, was the time LTV engineers discovered that giant McDonnell-Douglas made a basic error in stress calculations for the vertical tail of the C-17 transport, failing to factor in drag - something so basic I can see why it might have been overlooked. MD had to re-stress the assembly and LTV then built all the tail sections for the C-17 after that. I was going to write a black comedy about my time in the defense industry, and a manager gave me the perfect title: "You Can Buy Better, but You Can't Pay More".....
Wow. I wouldn't even have considered to different teams for the wings. Was that decision made because of internal differences in the wings?
I'm glad they caught the drag issue at some point. I remember a Mars vehicle that failed because one part of the team was using feet and the other meters.
That's a great title.
Yes, the Mars screw-up also involved Lockheed-Martin - L-M was using Imperial (feet/miles) and NASA was using metric (meters/kilometers). It did not go well..... As for the LTV non-matching wing issue, I am not sure why they had two teams designing the two wings instead of one - perhaps due to different equipment in each wing requiring different mountings and power supply details. Obviously, production Gulfstream Vs have matching wings.....
Very nice post. The bottleneck is serious, the European suppliers are not identified although you are implying PRC financial capability to "buy" said sources.
Much like they bought most of the rare earths and developed 90% of the world's capacity to process them.
Very interesting. .
Yet another great article filled with very interesting info. Thanks!
A herd is only as fast as its slowest runner.
Literally the medieval german poem collected by Benjamin Franklin:
For the want of a nail , the Kingdom was lost.
Thank you :)
Thank you for this analysis. Value chains are really some difficult beasts. Impressive when it performs. And very brittle indeed. (They remind me of AI in that way.) I am afraid the most important lesson I take away from this is the need for most countries to look very hard at such systems when they decide on weapons. For Ukraine? Build your own.
It's easier to build simpler systems on your own. Ballistic interceptor missiles are much more difficult to design and build than ballistic missiles, and Ukraine has been working on ballistic missiles since at least 2006.
I hope they are not working along then
This is bullshit. All you need is a license. Ukraine got the license, they'll start mass producing Patriots by the end of the year (2050).
Zelensky said they have approval. The White House has not confirmed or issued the paperwork. 2050 may, indeed, be a reasonable date for expectations.
Brilliant, Don. I hope all those people (none here on Sarcastosaurus of course) who think a magic wand can be waved and PAC-3s or Aster-30s will appear instantly read this. It needs to be circulated as widely as possible.
Thank you, Donald!
Once again, my thanks to Donald, for a very interesting post.
Thanks Don, this clears up much confusion. I also heard that Boeing is a bottleneck for PAC3 seeker heads.
Excellent detail 👍
Today i learn something news for me, thank cooper and hill fornthis dossier
Hej Tom, is it true that SU-57s are being used to complement A-50Us to detect low flying missiles/drones ?
Check this article and start with part one , thos is a good one:
https://xxtomcooperxx.substack.com/p/su-57-case-study-in-vaporware-from-b90?r=2dcuye&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web
nice, thank you
"Wartime economy optimizes for resiliency, redundancy while peacetime economy optimized for cost, profit."
While I may have just pulled this quote out of my rear end, I think it is true.
It gets even more fun when you introduce software supply chains, where the bottleneck is security or "provenness". If you have software that works, great. Until it stops working, or gets exploited and cannot be relied on anymore, then you have a possibly huge hole in your applicaton. Maybe the developers are no longer around to outline how it's supposed to work, and what the design tradeoffs are for remaking - or maybe they work for a hostile actor (joys of open source).
I forsee fun problems in the future for f-35 and any other programs where the government does not own the source.