Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Hans Torvatn's avatar

You wrote about the Ukrainian counterattack: «For all practical purposes, this is actually a classic ‘local counterattack into the flanks of an enemy advance’. Just run in style of this war as of 2026: with lots of drones and rather slow advance of ground forces. Not in form of ‘major movement of mechanised forces’: this is impossible because of enemy FPVs and mines.» Very well, from my armchair I agree. But that begs the question: How do you manage a large scale offensive in a world with FPVs and mines? Is it at all possible or are we back to the WW1 situation where large scale offensives are almost impossible?

Denys's avatar

> The Ukrainians have reached the ruined substation and the wastewater treatment plant, then turned north and punched into the Shevchenko District, before infiltrating towards the city centre. That’s where this advance came to an end, though: the ZSU did not manage to secure any of positions inside Chasiv Yar.

- ISW describes that in a different way, based on Rybar:

A Kremlin-affiliated Russian milblogger claimed on February 15 that exaggerated claims of Russian advances are complicating the situation for Russian forces in the Kostyantynivka direction. The milblogger claimed that recent footage indicates Ukrainian forces continue to conduct attacks toward central Chasiv Yar (northeast of Kostyantynivka) from positions in southwestern Chasiv Yar despite Russian claims of the seizure of the town. The milblogger claimed that newly released footage suggests Russian forces previously falsely claimed control of Chervone (east of Kostyantynivka).

43 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?